Buffalo taxpayers pick up tab for plastic surgeries, five-star hotels, limousines

November 28, 2012

Kyle Olson Kyle Olson

Kyle founded Education Action Group in 2007.
Find Kyle on Twitter.

Archive »

BUFFALO, N.Y. – Just call them the “Real School Employees of Buffalo.”

Like the rich folks in the famous television show with a similar name, employees of Buffalo public schools routinely spend a great deal of money on extravagant things like plastic surgery, airline travel, expensive hotels and limousines.

The only difference is that the wealthy people in “Real Housewives” are spending their own money. In Buffalo they’re throwing around taxpayer dollars.

EAGnews recently completed an inspection of credit card records and the check registry for the Buffalo City School District in 2011. We also filed a freedom of information request to measure the latest cost of the district’s infamous employee cosmetic surgery program.

The dollar figures we found were breathtaking, and not in a good way.

Gaylord Opryland Hotel

The amount spent on cosmetic surgery for teachers came to $2.7 million. The total cost for hotels, airline tickets, limousines and the like came to $196,986. You read it correctly. A struggling public school district with a budget deficit of nearly $50 million spent almost $3 million in one year on plastic surgery and travel. District officials declined an invitation to explain these expenses before publication of this story.

One local media outlet, WGRZ-TV (NBC 2), already picked up this story and ran a report last night.

We don’t suppose the taxpayers of Buffalo will be too amused the next time they are asked to approve a tax increase for general operations. School officials have already demonstrated they can’t handle large sums of money in any sort of responsible fashion. Who in their right mind would give them any more to waste?

Union negotiated facelifts

What’s more amazing than a struggling public school district paying the total cost of elective cosmetic surgery for employees?

The fact that the program has been public knowledge for a few years now, and nobody has done anything to stop it.

As the Atlantic put it in a 2010 story, “Hair removal. Miscrodermabrasian. Liposuction. If you name the procedure, it’s probably covered. This is a city where the average teacher makes $52,000 a year. The plastic surgery tab would pay salaries for 100 extra educators.”

The program is the result of a negotiated provision in the Buffalo teacher union collective bargaining agreement, dating back to the 1970s. In later decades cosmetic surgery boomed in America and doctors began advertising to Buffalo teachers in their union newsletter, according to the Atlantic.

By 2009, about 500 employees were taking advantage of this unbelievable perk. The district’s annual tab grew as high as $9 million in 2009.

When the program was exposed to the public a few years ago, Buffalo union boss Philip Rumore said he would be glad to drop the perk in the next round of contract negotiations. But Buffalo hasn’t had a new teachers contract since the last one expired in 2004, according to the Atlantic.

That’s because the state of New York allows teachers to keep working under the terms of expired contracts until a new pact is negotiated. Why would the Buffalo union want a new contract when the old one pays out so well?

At one point the school board offered to cancel 100 teacher layoffs if the union would drop the cosmetic surgery program for a year, according to The Atlantic. The union declined the offer.

“The urgency of negotiating a new contract really isn’t there,” Amber Dixon, a recent interim superintendent for the district, told The Atlantic. “You get to keep your benefits. You get to keep your cosmetic rider. You get to keep your 2.5 percent step increase. It makes getting back to the table difficult.”

Of course all of this is old news. The taxpayers of Buffalo long ago accepted the fact that they have to fork over hard earned dollars so teachers can get free nips and tucks.

But just out of curiosity, we decided to get an update on the annual cost of this monstrous waste of money. The school district responded politely to our request:

“Pursuant to your FOIL request dated October 15, 2012, the Buffalo public school district spent $2,728,201 on cosmetic procedures for members of the Buffalo Teachers Federation for the period of June 2011-July 2012.”

Hmm. $2.7 million. At least that’s less than the $5.2 million the district shelled out the year before.

“Please feel free to contact (so and so at some number) should you care to discuss the matter any further,” the school district letter continued.

No thanks. We’ve learned all we care to know about this sickening disposal of taxpayer dollars. Just let us know when somebody finds the courage to end this fiasco.

Big travel costs

Given the crazy cost of the cosmetic surgery program, one might expect Buffalo school officials to economize in other ways.

Caribe Royal Orlando

After all, they’re dealing with a budget deficit of roughly $49 million.

No such luck.

We found 199 credit card transactions at various hotels around the nation, totaling $80,784. Then we discovered 24 checks written to various hotels, costing another $47,704.

That brings the district’s one-year lodging tab to nearly $130,000, which might be nearly enough to employ two first-year teachers with benefits – if they don’t have plastic surgery performed.

What were some of the more expensive lodging bills?

Let’s see. The district had nine credit card charges for a total of $7,541 at the Hyatt Hotels Regency in Jersey City on July 11, 2011. Sounds like fun. There were eight charges for a total of $4,011 at Hyatt Hotels San Antonio on Feb. 28, 2011.

Five transactions at Residence Inns Downtown Tampa on Feb. 3, 2011 came to $4,975.  There were 11 charges totaling $4,163 at Residence Inns Greenbelt on May 15, 2011.  There were nine charges at the Hilton Saratoga Hotel on May 3, 2011 for $2,465.

It appears that checks were the preferred mode of payment for instate lodging. One check for $1,828 was written to the Darien Lake Theme Park Resort on July 8, 2011. Another for $1,560 was written to Marriott Hotel Corporation in Albany on Sept. 2, 2011, while one for $1,428 went to Hampton Inn and Suites in Poughkeepsie on April 15, 2011.

The largest single hotel transaction was for $36,870 at Buffalo’s own Adams Mark Hotel on July 22, 2011.

Of course school officials had to get to their destinations, which meant a lot of flying. We found 181 transactions with various airlines in 2011, costing the district $60,805.

That’s a lot of frequent flier miles. To be fair, the school district appears to have made an effort to fly budget airlines, like Jetblue, on a fairly frequent basis. But there were also plenty of bookings on more expensive airlines like United, Southwest and Delta.

Let’s not forget the limousine costs. District credit cards were used for $669 worth of service from Kings Limo Service, Moon Limo Services, RTC Chauffer Service and VC Limousine Service on various days in 2011. School officials, as mentioned above, failed to respond to our offer to explain these costs. But based on what we’ve heard from other districts around the nation, we can almost guess what they would have said:

Some or most of the money spent on travel came from state or federal grants. Some or most of the money was used for professional development trips. Expensive hotels were used because that’s where the conferences were.  Some of the money was spent on student travel.


Tax money is tax money, whether it comes from school coffers or the state or federal government. And Buffalo school officials spent a lot of it on questionable transactions in 2011. They may not have offered us an explanation, but we think they owe one to the taxpayers of their city.

Ashleigh Costello contributed to this report

From Around The Web
Tags: , , , , , , , , ,
Posted on: 16 Comments

Bookmark and Share

16 Responses

  1. sheinLV says:

    Hello city of Buffalo, are you there?

    • Walkerz says:

      They may be there, but their brains surely aren’t.

      • sean crowley says:

        No your little band of privatizers like to tell half truths and whip up all the cheerleaders like you to do their pitchfork and torch routine outside city hall. Ignorance isn’t bliss it’s alive and well at EAG. Keep drinking the privatizer kool aid dude.

  2. Walkerz says:

    unbelievably disgusting!!

    • sean crowley says:

      Especially since you know less than half the story.

      • irish19 says:

        By all means, enlighten us-if you can.

      • irish19 says:

        By all means, enlighten us-if you can.

        • Sami Cirpili says:

          I’ll enlighten you as there is a history to this.
          1) A few years ago (about 10) the district had multiple insurance companies provide policies for the district. The district knew it could save a few bucks if it went to one health care provider. So, without negotiation, in a move to save money, but not share any with the employees (teachers) who actually provide the service they moved to a single provider.
          2) The union litigated and won so the district was forced to return to multiple providers. However, the rider for cosmetic surgery was no longer offered by the provider.

          Uh-oh the district had to comply to restore the previous level of coverage. Their only option?? Self-insure (as nobody would provide the rider except at large cost). Of course, self insurance is great if nobody collects on it, but alas, people learned of the district’s self-insurance pot and decided to use some of that cash.

          FOUL! Cried the district, see those greedy teachers, getting free surgery. But you never heard anything about this rider in the past 40 years or so that it had been in the contract. Only when the district began self-insuring did they start to make a big stink. Could the district save money by negotiating this out? You bet.

          This stupid web-zine wants to hammer the sound bites home to the ditto-heads without actually reporting facts (as they can be so hard to understand)…

  3. Smokewagon1984 says:

    Only 2.7 million dollars to make the employees pretty. WOW!!! What a deal.

  4. sean crowley says:

    This is pure bullshit. Please tell the history of the cosmetic rider if you know it. No I didn’t think so. Did you know that unions have to negotiate anything in a contract with management? Yeah that’s true, management had to approve this but you don’t know anything about it or why it’s still in the contract. You also failed to mention that spending is down from close to half a million when the last Super was in power. Oh is that because he was a charter supporter ? But then again you’re not here to tell the truth just to waterboard it til yo can make it fit your shameless hack agenda. Hey I am waaay impressed with your grizzled vet of two whole years of teaching junior high. Wow. He might have last 20 minutes with the jr high guys I’ve taught. No, probably more like 10. People see through all of your lies and your pathetic attempt to make money off kids. Your game is about over so enjoy it.

  5. Magic1955 says:

    You should look over your shoulder, I am sure by now one of the union thugs have been assigned to teach you not in interfere in union business.
    This kind of thing is standard practice for any union shop nation wide and not only the teachers, the corruption is the union itself

    • sean crowley says:

      Union thugs ? You have the Walton family in your corner — the greediest, most miserly bunch of shitheads to ever under pay a worker. With the company you keep you really need to be careful about name calling. How about kiddie fiddler KJ, you know Mr. Rhee who forgot to put his clothes on when he wanted to hug a teen age girl in his care? Have fun being Goliath for now but we all know how that ended up.

    • sean crowley says:

      p.s. maybe a union teacher can be assigned to teach you how to write in English, what the hell does your gibberish even mean anyway?

  6. lex says:

    Buffalo fire fighters, cops and their families do the same things with the exact same insurance. just saying

  7. sean crowley says:

    The more I read of this rag the worse it gets. Even James OKeefe would be embarassed to be associated with this level of lowlife hackery. Good luck getting rich while screwing kids out of their educations.

Leave a Reply